The New Observer Book Reviews,UK Affairs Book Reviews Vassal State: How America Runs Britain

Vassal State: How America Runs Britain

The theme of this book is how the UK is being taken over by US Corporations, especially in the sphere of IT cloud services, and by equity capital. This is detrimental to sovereignty and stifles the development of home-grown businesses. Accountability is lost. A notorious example of this is ownership of the water company Thames Water; foreign investors are little concerned about polluting British rivers. (Actually, US ownership is not a factor in Thames Water, but the general issue about foreign investment and lack of accountability holds).

The author makes a convincing case for his basic premise. One problem is a lack of clear, solid, unambiguous data proving his point. However, as the author points out, the fact that there is a lack of data itself points to a lack of interest in the political class in this matter. For example in official statistics foreign business activity may be linked to Luxembourg, even though the ultimate business is American. In official statistics very little attempt is made to track the American take-over. As a result of this lack of clear, organized, data the author has to rely on disparate sources. Here are a few examples:

Sales by US Multinationals as a percentage of UK GDP: 25%. [1]

percentage of workforce employed by US multinationals: 4-6% (higher figure if we factor in businesses fronted via e.g. Luxembourg) [1]

“larger US corporations” earned $18 profit billion from UK in 2019. [1] – IRS figure, again the author argues an underestimate as it does not account for profits streamed through Ireland, Netherlands and Luxembourg.

Americans now own more of the UK than all of the EU nations combined. [2]

The author criticises the UK’s “open” approach to FDI – all FDI is indiscriminately welcomed and claimed as “investment”. However; much of this so-called “investment” is private equity buying out UK businesses to squeeze profit out of them, not genuine investment which creates new jobs. Apparently, UK government statistics do not distinguish between the two. Politicians, fraudulently, boast about overall FDI numbers without admitting that much of it is more like finanical profiteering than a real contribution to the economy.

In addition, the author points to US dominance of major cloud, streaming, payment and online shopping services. A UK customer pays Amazon for the item and probably uses a US dominated payment processor to pay for it. Government is a heavy purchaser of US Cloud services. Amazon collects more than 30% of all UK online spending! Meta and Google collect 66% of all UK online ad spending. [3] Many of these services create dependency – they tie people to them, and make it hard to choose alternatives. (This resonates with Ivan Illich’s criticisms of top-down businesses which aim to build in dependency and repeat use). The Defence sector and NHS are also big purchasers of services and products from US multinationals.

US equity buys into sensitive areas of the economy, such as old people’s homes. And we can assume the motive is not care. US Equity company Blackstone bought a care provider Southern Cross in 2004 and re-structured it for profit. Critics argue that this restructuring led to its final collapse, some years after Blackstone had sold it. [4] In general once a company is bought up by private equity there is a loss in transparency; its information is not longer disclosable. Private equity traditionally aimed to buy businesses, improve profitability and then re-sell, though more recently there has been a trend towards longer term milking. Private equity firms tend to aim to reduce pension obligations and avoid regulation. All this has a knock-on effect. Even businesses which are not bought out must avert the risk of being bought by themselves increasing focus on ‘the bottom line’ rather than any longer-term sustainable social objectives. Another example; in 2018 the UK government sold Britain’s railway arches to US private equity company Blackstone. Blackstone went on to increase rents, driving many small businesses out.

US corporations are adroit at reducing their contribution to the UK tax base. Typically they do this by routing their UK profits to front companies in European countries with low rates of corporate tax.

At this point, we have to point out that the argument of the author is in support of capitalistism; he just prefers UK companies to be deeveloping, and making the profits! In reality, UK investors may have just as little sense of social solidarity as Blackstone. The author does not address this core political question. There may be some benefits if the corporations are Brtiish, such as greater transsparency and less tax avoidance – but he does not explain how switching to more British businesses will solve many of the main problems he identifies such equity resstructuring businesses for profit and large corporations gaining and then leveraging monopoly possitions.

The following figure is from a House of Lords report citing an industry source, not actually from Hanton’s book but gives an idea of the scale of private equity involvement in the UK economy altogether, not just US:

Private equity plays a significant role in the UK economy. The British Private Equity and Venture Capital Association (BVCA), which advocates on behalf of private equity, contends that private capital-backed companies now generate £199bn annually in GDP and support 2.5mn jobs—up from 2.2mn in 2023.[14] The BVCA also maintains that private equity and venture capital backed businesses directly support approximately 7% of UK GDP, 8% of employment, and 9% gross earnings in 2025 [5]

Another industry source puts the share of US involvement in private equity in the UK at 33% in 2025. [6] – Thus (rough estimate) total US Private Equity involvment may be just under a £70bn contribution to GDP – about equivalent to the Defence budget.

From Hanton’s point of view this “support” is not necessarily benign. At any event these are private, non-transparent entities with a strictly financial interest in the British economy.

One strange ommission from the book is any mention of the Agreement on Government Procurement (GPA). This is a supplemental treaty to the WTO which the UK has signed and under which the UK government is obliged to consider all bids for public procurement equally from any participating country (with some caveats and allowed exceptions). The author will not get the UK to start focusing more on British businesses until the UK exits from this agreement.

This book suffers from a lack of a single clear section where data is laid out comprehensively. To some extent that is, as the author points out, symptomatic of the problem. The government is turning a blind eye – and just not collecting the data. That said; the author could have tried to sort out his sources into a single clear page. In general, the style of the book reads a bit more like a businessman giving a talk about a pet subject, than a disciplined piece of academic research. That said, it is well-organised. The author has an important point to make, and he makes it persuasively. Well worth a read.

Vassal State: How America Runs Britain Angus Hanton. Swift Press . 2024

Buy on Amazon

Notes

  1. p31 Kindle edition
  2. p39
  3. p66
  4. p109
  5. https://lordslibrary.parliament.uk/private-equity-role-in-the-uk-economy/
  6. https://www.grantthornton.co.uk/news-centre/global-private-equity-tracker/